Work Packages

WP5 – Labour market / public service impacts

← Back to Work Packages

While there is substantial research on the impact of migration on the labour market, there is less evidence on the broader consequences of those labour market impacts on well-being and public services such as health care. Using data from five northern and southern European countries, this work package will investigate the role of spillover effects from the labour market to the broader economy, well-being, and public services. We put particular emphasis on differences in impacts between EU citizens and third country nationals (TCNs).

The analysis is based on the observation that if mobility has a negative impact on local workers’ wages or increases their unemployment there will be implications for government revenues and native use of public benefits. In this case, natives will pay fewer taxes and make more use of public benefits. However, previous evidence suggests that inflows of low-skilled migrants often push local workers into more complex occupations which require more cultural knowledge and are less manual-intensive (Ortega and Verdugo, 2011; Peri and Sparber, 2009).

One consequence of this impact is an increase in the share of natives working in more complex occupations with higher wages and with better working conditions. These dynamics have multiple implications for the host economy. If natives have higher incomes they will contribute more to government revenues and make less use of social benefits. Likewise, better working conditions can lead to better health outcomes and less use of health facilities (Mazzonna and Giuntella, 2015).

This work package will examine these issues, asking:

  • What is the impact of EU and non-EU mobility on the employment levels/rates of native workers, and on the wages of native workers?
  • What is the impact of these flows on the occupational distribution of native workers? Do natives move into more complex occupations in response to EU and non-EU migration?
  • What are the implications of these changes in labour market dynamics? Are natives less/more likely to claim social benefits? Do they have better/worse long-term health outcomes that decrease/increase their use of health services? What are the implications for their tax contributions?
  • To what extent and in which ways do the analysed impacts differ between immigration from within the EU and from outside the EU?



Working Papers

Effects on Utilisation, Health and User Satisfaction When Access to Health Care is Limited

Immigration and the Reallocation of Work Health Risks

Immigration and Unemployment Benefits: Evidence from Germany



Who's Involved

Judit Vall Castello, Pompeu Fabra University
Nicolau Martín, Pompeu Fabra University
Catia Nicodemo, University of Oxford
Carlos Vargas-Silva, COMPAS
Osea Giuntella, COMPAS
Esther Arenas-Arroyo, COMPAS

Latest Tweets

Don't forget to register for next week's webinar on the possibilities and limitations of intra-EU migration data, brought to you by @KatrinMarchand and @MelissaSiegel1. 19 Nov, 10:00am CET. The webinar is free, but registration is necessary in order to receive the link👇👇


On 19 November REMINDER researchers @KatrinMarchand and @MelissaSiegel1 from @UNUMERIT @MaastrichtU will host a webinar on what the available data can (and can't) tell us about intra-EU migration. Free and all welcome. Register here to receive the link:

Message to our students - To vote in the upcoming UK General Election, you need to register by midnight on 26 Nov. You can register online if you are eligible.

Want to be part of a crowd-sourced, public #photography exhibition? @snapshotox is inviting entrants from all walks of life to engage and participate from 2-9 Nov, by showing us a snapshot of what #migration in #Oxford means to you! #ESRCFestival @MigObs

Signup to our newsletter

Enter your email address to get the latest news direct to your inbox